Thursday, August 13, 2009

What Sides Go With Bratwurst

year Darwin


150th anniversary of the publication of The Origin of Species in 1859. And curiously, I find in the library of Ibrahim - which I have thoroughly painted portrait! - A book in French, and he did not so much, entitled "Man where is it? The answers of science and the Scriptures" (Dr. Michael Bucaille, ed. Seghers 1981). An old book, of course - and God, if he exists, knows how his creatures have made discoveries in genetics and biochemistry other since then - but full of interesting thoughts and, even though (or because?) Its stated goal is to reconcile believers, Christianity and Islam, with scientific advances by enabling them to believe "yet" it is not, in my view, retrograde.

Quran
Regarding the Koran, which the author has studied Arabic, learned for the occasion in the text, it is full of praise for the prescient images to be confirmed then by science, particularly as regards the origin of life liquid (both life on earth and human reproduction). Admittedly, the verses quoted, and unless I am able to detect any misuse, pay little to the side frontal attacks in the light of knowledge scientists.


The Bible In the Bible, it immediately establishes that the narratives of Genesis do not correspond to any reality they (the earth is created before the sun and the day too ... This kind of detail has the misfortune a generation of astronomers!). A historical review of the constitution of the Bible, its multiple authors and negotiations that have taken place between the Fathers of the Church, with the objective to adopt a particular practice by giving an overriding justification. All this makes the Bible - unlike the Koran which is directly dictated by God to Mohammed, then recited word for word to his disciples to be transcribed as is, and is therefore a divine word to accept the report in its entirety - all this makes the Bible so unreliable and should be handled with caution. Vatican 2 has, according to the author, confirmed the obsolescence of certain contents of the Old Testament and knowing that the new has sometimes relied on the old ...
short, everything other than the author (well, me) would have concluded that we can not trust the Bible. He classifies the stories of Genesis in the content clearly written by men biased by certain intentions, and outdated. These are these intentions, their message to be identified, and forget the actual content of the genesis. Whereby, he considered the rest of the building biblical saved. After how to cut the tree branches he dies? "

Science
Regarding the theory of evolution and natural selection, the author expresses doubts about a number of conclusions could be drawn rather hastily at a time when the battle raged between clerics entrenched in their positions more than thousands of scientists and stretched to make them let go. Man, even near the monkey could still have been a special creation, because there was not really the film's transition from man to monkey. And even if it descended from apes, the transition to the man could in itself be a creative. The author promotes the idea of creative evolution, that God would drive. The establishment would not be the work of a single start, anyway allegory in Genesis, but would be made continuously. A solution which confirms well the funeral of creationism dear to the generation of our grandparents, but I find elegant left God a place. What does the Church? The author notes

many issues not necessarily resolved that revolve around the evolution and natural selection. And, to think twice as often in science, each issue resolved opens the door to 10 more. So if one wants to agree on the definition of God as we do not understand this, there is still enough room for God. (Where things get complicated is when we must begin to characterize this God and what he expects from us, and what it would do us good to repeat that it is big and strong, while he knows we did well without him in constantly harping on!)

As the paths of travelers are no less mysterious than those guided the Magi by the evening star, the Science & Vie No. 1101 of June 2009, seemed attracted to me as "the village" (no, not "cave"!) a backpackers (hostel) in Kuala Lumpur. "What Darwin did not know. The theory of evolution today." Finally, this survey reveals a eulogy of the British scientist, whose theory fate confirmed and reinforced by the latest discoveries, even if natural selection takes in ways that were not necessarily at the time were seen or amendments Genetic take cross paths that are not those of the pure heredity. So much the better (as well not waste time on false theories). But it is also miraculous, and a little scary, we did not find any better than chance to explain the evolution after 150 years of research.

We would have liked also that the major issues that remain to be recalled that the disturbing phenomenon of the survival of archaic forms of life, or, conversely, to coordinate development of complex shapes, are highlighted.

Some questions do not seem entirely clear
1 - If natural selection plays between species or individuals with the smallest differences, why not between entirely different species living together in countless numbers. Biodiversity should be restricted by natural selection, leaving about every environment that a few dominant species and few competitors.

2 - If one accepts that the creation of a complex structure like the eye, or a radical change as the transition from water to air, is incompatible with slight variations on spread very long periods, and thus the result of rapid change "block", that the discovery of cells strains appears to allow, however, we see how bad mutations left to chance to reach this result.

3 - transmission of a mutation to offspring seems struggling to explain that a population (animal) right, sometimes widely dispersed, mute. Certainly, if this mutation was fast, "block", one could imagine that the mutated population is the descendant of the individual single mutant, the rest of the species dying out. But if it's a long series of infinitesimal changes that it is hard to imagine that the species is refounded in every generation by the withering away of individuals nonmutated the benefit of descendants of the descendants of the transfer. Transmission "horizontal", not to the offspring but to congénaires, for example by viruses, seems necessary and recognized. But is it enough?

4 - Should we not observe species in the process of changing, species being stagnant, and a continuum of variety more or less favorable, taking nature in all directions before you remove those less viable? Paleontology does not provide more than zoology, I think he, of intermediate forms, but only species accomplished.

5 - This should, in particular, apply to the man he should be a fairly diverse variety. Instead, and apart from superficial differences in appearance, there is no doubt that this is a single homogeneous species, having, as far as I know, a unique genome and universal. Must we conclude, as Mr. Bucaille, the evolution of man is finished, which, given the rapid increase in size or life expectancy (at least in developed countries) or the increasing complexity of its terrestrial accomplishments that could still affect the size of his brain, does not appear to be obvious.

short, some interesting objections of Dr. Bucaille really do not find answer in this inventory Science & Vie. So, dear reader, you who are more knowledgeable than me about this, can you tell me a little innocence, with a useful bibliography for me and save me from ridicule me publicly before the world with my scientific and philosophical claims?

0 comments:

Post a Comment